People's Democracy(Weekly Organ of the Communist Party of India (Marxist) |
Vol.
XXVI No. 51 December 29,2002 |
Funds
for
Minority
Bashing
Exposures
Rattle
Sangh
Parivar
Spartacus
A
NEW
game
has
begun.
Stung
by
reports
in
the
media
about
select
American
corporate
funds
flowing
in
merrily
to
finance
the
Sangh
Parivar’s
hate
campaigns,
and
amid
reports
that
some
American
corporates
have
started
realising
that
their
charity
was
being
misused
and
withdrawing
when
the
Gujarat
elections
were
approaching,
the
Parivar
began
to
target
the
media
and
select
presspersons
along
with
the
retired
justices
and
others
who
were
associated
with
an
Editors
Guild’s
fact-finding
team
to
Gujarat.
The
RSS
mouthpiece
Organiser,
in
its
issue
dated
December
1,
spoke
of
the
“malicious
media”
and
charged
well
known
journalists
like
B
G
Verghese,
Daleep
Padgaonkar,
The
Times
of
India,
and
Mid
Day
editor
Aakar
Patel
with
following
a
Marxist
methodology.
The
Organiser
analysis
was
based
on
a
report
prepared
by
the
Hindu
Vivek
Kendra
which,
according
to
it,
purports
to
expose
the
bias
in
the
English
media.
Attempts
have
also
begun
to
disturb
functions
critical
of
the
Sangh
Parivar,
even
in
the
capital.
What
has
irked
them
most,
however,
is
a
report
titled
“US
corporates
funding
hate,”
based
on
tax
returns
filed
by
these
companies,
and
published
by
the
Campaign
to
Stop
Funding
Hate.
The
Campaign
comprises
top
academicians
and
researchers.
According
to
the
report,
global
software
major
Cisco
Systems
donated
70,000
dollars
in
just
one
year
to
a
US-based
Sangh
Parivar
fund-raising
outfit,
the
Indian
Development
and
Relief
Fund
(IDRF).
The
latter
has
channeled
millions
of
dollars
to
Sangh
Parivar
organisations,
like
the
Vanvasi
Kalyan
Ashram,
linked
with
anti-minority
violence
in
many
states.
According
to
the
report,
Cisco’s
contribution
as
per
tax
submission
was
5
per
cent
of
the
IDRF’s
total
cash
corpus
in
1999.
If
the
contributions
of
company
employees
are
added,
the
total
works
out
to
1,33,000
dollars
or
about
10
per
cent.
The
same
holds
good
for
other
large
US
corporations
such
as
Sun
Computers,
Oracle,
and
Hewlett
Pacard.
Unsuspecting
corporations
end
up
giving
large
amounts
of
money
as
‘matching
funds’
to
the
IDRF
as
the
NRI
employees
of
these
firms
donate
to
the
IDRF,
according
to
observers.
The
IDRF,
a
registered
tax-exempt
charity,
claims
to
be
a
non-sectarian
organisation
raising
funds
for
‘development’
and
‘relief’
works
in
India.
As
a
result,
it
is
also
listed
on
‘Network
of
Good,’
a
charity
portal
set
up
by
AOL-Tim
Warner
and
Cisco,
directing
funds
to
good
causes.
The
Campaign
charged
that
the
IDRF
has
been
channeling
millions
of
dollars
to
organisations
that
are
connected
with
the
Sangh
Parivar
and
implicated
in
the
worst
of
communal
politics
and
violence.
According
to
the
IDRF’s
own
reports,
it
disbursed
close
to
4
million
dollars
between
1994
and
2000
to
dozens
of
Sangh
Parivar
organisations
all
over
India.
In
2000
alone,
using
US
government
tax-exemption
status
for
charities,
the
IDRF
collected
1.7
million
dollars,
mainly
from
US
corporations
and
Indians
in
America.
Although
the
IDRF
claims
that
it
supports
NGOs
engaged
in
“strengthening
the
roots
of
a
democratic,
secular…
India,”
82
per
cent
of
its
designated
funds
were
sent
to
the
Parivar’s
organisations
---
those
affiliated
with
or
controlled
by
the
RSS
and
the
VHP.
Only
two
per
cent
of
the
organisations
it
funded
between
1994
and
2000
can
be
recognised
as
non-sectarian
organisations.
As
for
the
Sangh,
it
has
always
laid
claims
to
its
swadeshi
credentials
as
against
the
‘foreign
funding’
received
by
Muslim
and
Christian
organisations.
But
the
said
report
makes
clear
the
shallowness
of
the
claim
as
well
as
the
fact
that
these
“foreign
funds”
of
the
RSS
are
used
to
promote
sectarian
hatred.
A
substantial
proportion
of
the
IDRF’s
fund-raising
is
done
through
electronic
means.
But
there
is
ample
evidence
that
the
IDRF
is
obtaining
much
of
its
funds
by
hiding
the
sectarian
and
communal
nature
of
its
activities
from
US
corporations.
The
IDRF’s
strategy
to
collect
funds
is
simple.
As
Indian
professionals’
migration
to
the
US
has
zoomed
over
the
last
two
decades,
especially
in
the
software
sector,
groups
of
Sangh
operatives,
in
each
of
the
large
high-tech
firms
with
liberal
aid-giving
policies,
have
worked
to
put
the
IDRF
on
the
corporations’
list
of
grantees.
The
swayamsevaks
within
US
corporations
push
the
IDRF
as
the
‘best’
and
the
‘only’
way
to
provide
funding
for
“development
and
relief
work
in
India,”
thus
causing
not
only
other
unsuspecting
employees
but
also
the
corporations
themselves
to
fund
the
Sangh
in
India,
the
report
says.
What
is
perhaps
morally
more
reprehensible
than
individuals
directing
money
to
the
IDRF,
knowing
that
most
or
all
of
it
will
be
used
for
Sangh
activities,
is
the
subterfuge
involved
in
misusing
the
generosity
of
well
meaning
individuals
and
organisations
for
securing
the
hate
money,
the
report
further
says.
The
ideological
de
facto
tie-up
with
Mussolini’s
Italy
and
Hitler’s
Germany
is
well
known.
It
is
also
becoming
clear
that
even
the
Vishwa
Hindu
Parishad
(VHP)
is
active
in
the
US
to
generate
support.
Similarly,
during
prime
minister
Vajpayee’s
official
visit
to
the
US,
there
was
a
‘Hindutva
Summit’
organised
by
the
VHP
and
its
affiliates.
But
not
so
known
is
the
fact
that
the
VHP
unit
in
the
UK
is
being
probed.
The
VHP
is
reported
to
have
several
international
branches,
with
offices
in
the
US,
UK
and
Canada.
There
is
also
another
outfit,
Overseas
Friends
of
the
BJP
(OFBJP),
which
also
does
the
same
job.