People's Democracy(Weekly Organ of the Communist Party of India (Marxist) |
Vol.
XXVII No. 06 February 09, 2003 |
AT
a
time
our
people
are
facing
one
of
the
toughest
periods
in
their
life,
the
Sangh
Parivar
has
moved
one
more
pawn
on
the
political
chessboard
to
rescue
the
BJP
from
the
predicament
of
its
own
creation.
IT
is
a
well-known
fact
that
the
BJP
has
miserably
failed
on
all
fronts.
Take
the
case
of
Gujarat
where
the
BJP
recently
registered
a
big
victory.
Only
on
January
31
did
The
Indian
Express
report
how
the
five-year
BJP
rule
in
the
state
has
emptied
the
coffers
of
the
state
government,
so
much
so
that
the
second
Modi
government
was
compelled
to
send
a
long
SOS
to
the
centre
for
additional
funds.
In
terms
of
per
capita
state
GDP,
the
state
has
slipped
from
the
second
to
seventh
or
eighth
place.
A
large
number
of
villages
are
in
the
grip
of
a
severe
drought,
but
relief
is
either
absent
or
paltry
at
the
best.
Large
tracts
of
this
prosperous
state
are
still
crying
for
potable
water.
This
is
no
new
situation,
however.
Now
and
again
media
have
been
reporting
about
the
worsening
situation
in
the
state,
but
the
earlier
BJP
governments,
under
Keshubhai
Patel
or
under
Narendra
Modi,
cared
a
hoot
about
it.
However,
a
far
worse
situation
is
facing
the
country
as
a
whole,
thanks
to
the
anti-people,
anti-national
policies
the
BJP-led
regime
at
the
centre
is
pursuing.
The
economy
has
fallen
as
though
into
a
bottomless
pit;
the
last
few
years
have
seen
a
dismal
growth.
The
peasantry
was
never
before
in
such
a
miserable
situation
as
it
is
today;
already
more
than
a
thousand
peasants
have
committed
suicide.
The
working
class
is
facing
a
massive
attack
in
the
form
of
closures,
retrenchment
and
layoffs.
Even
navratna
public
sector
units
are
being
sold
to
private
parties
for
a
song.
Unemployment
is
growing
by
leaps
and
bounds.
The
situation
of
poverty
at
the
ground
level
is
giving
a
lie
to
all
statistics-mongering.
On
February
3,
the
prime
minister
shamelessly
claimed
that
his
regime
did
not
allow
a
single
person
to
die
of
starvation.
Which
means
that
he
has
even
lost
his
memory
and
(not
to
talk
of
other
parts
of
the
country)
forgotten
the
famine-stricken
people
in
Orissa
who
had
to
eat
mango
kennels
and
several
dozens
died
of
hunger.
At
the
same
time,
the
regime
has
proved
to
be
the
most
shamelessly
pro-imperialist
regime
in
independent
India.
And
to
cap
it
all
this,
the
BJP
is
busy
capturing
all
the
educational
and
cultural
bodies.
It
is
out
to
saffronise
the
whole
education
system
with
a
view
to
producing
a
generation
of
bigots
and
fanatics
who
can
serve
as
cannonfodders
in
its
battle
for
a
theocratic
state.
As
all
these
aspects
have
already
been
dealt
with
in
these
columns,
no
detailed
reiteration
is
needed.
It
is
in
such
a
situation
that
the
BJP
has
but
one
hope
---
to
sidetrack
the
real
issues
facing
the
people
and
to
rouse
the
worst
possible
passions
in
a
bid
to
mislead
the
people.
Its
victory
in
Gujarat
assembly
elections
has
also
made
the
BJP
believe
that
it
can
still
cross
the
hurdle
in
the
coming
assembly
polls
and
then
in
the
Lok
Sabha
poll
if
only
it
runs
a
strident
communal
drive
all
over
the
country.
This
gives
an
idea
of
what
the
real
meaning
of
the
tall
talks
of
replicating
Gujarat
is.
THE
BJP
and
the
rest
of
the
saffron
brigade
have
already
swung
into
action
and
geared
themselves
into
the
poll
mode.
Even
though
the
so-called
National
Agenda
for
Governance
has
in
actuality
been
nothing
more
than
a
piece
of
paper
all
these
four-odd
years,
the
BJP
is
trying
to
dump
it
midway.
It
has
already
made
clear
to
its
allies
that
it
won’t
be
bound
by
this
agenda
in
the
state
assembly
elections.
This
is
a
plain
enough
indication
that
the
BJP
won’t
hesitate
to
raise
the
contentious
issues
---
the
temple
issue,
article
370
and
common
civil
code
---
that
it
had
had
to
put
on
the
backburner
in
order
to
grab
power
at
the
centre.
At
the
same
time,
the
BJP
has
already
effected
no-insignificant
changes
in
the
union
cabinet
as
well
as
in
party
organisation
---
all
in
view
of
the
communal
campaign
that
it
wants
to
run
anew.
Its
desperation
is
evident
from
the
fact,
for
example,
that
in
order
to
placate
the
Bhumihar
caste
it
had
to
re-induct
into
the
union
cabinet
the
same
C
P
Thakur
whom
it
had
not
very
long
ago
dumped
after
dubbing
as
“inefficient.”
The
BJP’s
desperation
is
also
growing
with
various
sections
of
the
toiling
people
beginning
to
rise
in
protest.
The
depth
of
their
discontent
is
evident
from
just
one
example,
among
scores.
Even
though
the
RSS-controlled
BMS
kept
aloof
from
the
coal
workers’
strike
a
few
months
ago,
a
large
number
of
BMS
members
among
coal
workers
spontaneously
joined
the
action.
Students
and
youth
are
agitated,
and
so
are
women
who
are
directly
feeling
the
pinch
of
the
worsening
economic
situation
as
it
is
they
who
run
the
household.
Employees
and
other
sections
of
the
middle
class
are
also
facing
a
bleak
future,
some
for
themselves
immediately
and
some
for
their
wards.
Even
though
the
regime
has
assured
(!)
the
serving
employees
about
not
implementing
the
retrograde
Kelkar
committee
recommendations,
and
the
pensioners
about
not
slashing
the
interest
rates
on
their
savings
any
further,
clearly
these
assurances
are
to
last
only
till
the
next
Lok
Sabha
polls.
(On
the
BJP’s
real
intentions
in
this
regard,
see
the
lead
item
in
The
Economic
Times
of
January
31.)
Workers
of
the
HPCL
and
BPCL,
companies
that
are
the
latest
to
be
put
on
auction,
are
going
to
launch
a
strike
soon.
NALCO
workers
in
Orissa
have
so
far
prevented
any
private
bidders
from
entering
the
company’s
premises.
True,
the
actions
of
all
these
sections
have
been
uncoordinated
so
far.
But
they
are
bound
to
get
coordinated
sooner
or
later.
The
opening
day
of
the
coming
budget
session
of
parliament
is
set
to
witness
a
united
protest
march
by
working
class
and
others,
to
be
followed
by
a
powerful
industrial
action.
To
come
out
of
such
a
predicament,
the
BJP
has
but
two
options.
Either
it
has
to
give
up
its
present
set
of
policies
or
it
must
do
something
to
divert
the
mass
discontent
into
wrong
directions.
As
the
first
option
is
out
of
question
in
view
of
the
party’s
own
class
character
and
no
less
because
of
the
pressure
of
its
masters
abroad,
it
is
the
second
course
the
BJP
is
seeking
to
follow,
more
so
after
its
initial
success
in
Gujarat.
THE
farce
of
a
threat
doled
out
by
the
Vishwa
Hindu
Parishad
(VHP)
to
the
union
government
is
but
a
part
of
this
very
calculated
game.
From
the
earlier
unspecific
threat
that
the
centre
must
clear
the
ground
for
temple
construction
in
Ayodhya,
the
VHP
has
now
graduated
to
a
specific
threat.
Its
demand
is
that
the
centre
must
hand
it
over
about
40
out
of
the
67
acres
of
land
the
union
government
acquired
in
1994,
before
February
22
when
the
VHP
is
to
hold
a
so-called
“Dharma
Sansad”
at
New
Delhi.
Three
points
are
noteworthy
here.
Firstly,
the
VHP’s
claim
is
that
this
part
of
the
acquired
land
is
undisputed
and
hence
the
centre
must
not
have
any
problem
in
handing
it
over
to
the
VHP.
This
is
a
bogus
argument,
to
say
the
least.
For,
in
case
this
land
is
handed
over
to
the
VHP,
there
would
not
remain
any
passage
to
the
site
where
the
demolished
Babri
Masjid
once
stood.
This
means
an
outright,
even
if
unjustified,
victory
for
the
VHP.
Secondly,
the
VHP
has
put
forth
this
demand
while
knowing
very
well
the
Supreme
Court’s
opinion
about
the
acquired
land.
The
apex
court
has
specifically
restrained
the
centre
from
transferring
any
part
of
the
acquired
land
to
any
party
till
the
final
decision
of
the
case.
Moreover,
the
court
has
also
disallowed
any
puja,
construction
and
other
such
activities
on
this
piece
of
land
till
the
case
is
pending.
Thus,
as
a
matter
of
fact,
the
VHP’s
demand
is
tantamount
to
a
deliberate
contempt
of
the
court.
But
this
is
nothing
surprising.
The
VHP
has
already
---
ridiculously
and
at
the
same
time
ominously
---
declared
that
it
would
abide
by
the
court
verdict
only
if
it
is
in
its
favour.
Finally,
one
will
have
to
ask:
why
is
it
that
the
VHP
holds
a
Dharma
(!)
Sansad
or
some
such
drama
only
when
an
election
is
around
the
corner?
The
last
such
drama
took
place
at
Allahabad
in
2000
when
assembly
elections,
especially
in
Uttar
Pradesh
but
also
in
Uttaranchal,
Punjab,
Manipur
and
Pondicherry,
were
approaching
fast.
The
latest
visit
of
Swami
Jayendra
Saraswati,
the
Shankracharya
of
Kanchi,
to
the
capital
is
to
be
seen
in
this
very
light.
Though
the
swami’s
meeting
with
the
prime
minister
was
officially
described
as
a
“courtesy
call,”
the
Ayodhya
issue
was
very
much
in
the
centre
of
their
discussion.
A
gamut
of
BJP
leaders,
including
union
ministers,
as
well
as
RSS
leaders
also
met
the
swami
for
the
same
purpose.
What
transpired
in
the
prime
minister’s
meeting
with
the
swami
is
still
not
very
clear.
Yet,
going
by
press
reports,
one
guesses
that
the
Supreme
Court’s
injunction
about
the
said
67
acres
of
land
very
much
weighed
on
their
minds.
This
gives
credence
to
the
news,
already
afloat,
that
behind
the
back
of
the
people
the
centre
is
trying
to
devise
some
or
other
method
to
bypass
the
court
injunction.
There
is
also
floating
the
news
that
Arun
Jaitley
has
been
re-inducted
into
the
union
cabinet
as
law
minister
precisely
to
clear
the
legal
hurdles
in
way
of
temple
construction.
To
remind
the
readers,
this
Swami
Jayendra
Saraswati
is
precisely
the
person
who
had
made
a
similar
attempt
last
year
also.
At
that
time,
after
meeting
a
delegation
of
the
All
India
Muslim
Personal
Law
Board
(AIMPLB),
the
swami
had
unilaterally
announced
to
the
media
that
a
solution
to
the
Ayodhya
dispute
had
been
reached
with
the
concurrence
of
the
AIMPLB.
It
is
another
thing
that
very
soon
the
said
announcement
proved
to
be
a
hoax.
At
that
time,
the
AIMPLB
came
out
with
a
clarification
that
it
was
only
given
a
set
of
proposals
for
consideration
and
that
no
agreement
had
been
reached
during
its
meeting
with
the
swami.
Then
within
two
days
of
the
episode,
a
full
meeting
of
the
AIMPLB
had
rejected
the
proposals
it
had
received.
It
was
natural,
as
the
so-called
proposals
were
nothing
but
a
rehash
of
the
VHP
demands.
And
now
the
same
godman
is
out
to
play
nobody
knows
what
mischief!
Be
that
as
it
may,
one
thing
is
certain.
The
Sangh
Parivar
has
absolutely
no
regard
for
the
rule
of
law,
and
has
tried
to
bypass
the
judicial
process
whenever
it
could.
How
it
did
not
allow
the
law
to
take
its
course,
is
evident
also
from
the
way
it
used
the
UP
chief
minister,
Ms
Mayawati,
to
withdraw
the
notification
regarding
the
constitution
of
a
special
court
in
regard
to
the
Babri
demolition
case.
The
purpose
was
as
clear
as
daylight:
to
get
L
K
Advani,
M
M
Joshi
and
46
other
luminaries
of
the
saffron
brigade
off
the
hook.
It
appears
a
similar
game
of
circumventing
the
law
is
again
under
way.
At
a
function
of
Anganwadi
workers
on
February
4
morning,
the
prime
minister
is
reported
to
have
said
that
the
Ayodhya
dispute
could
be
solved
either
through
talks
or
through
a
court
verdict.
That
is
so
far
so
good.
But
the
same
prime
minister
met
the
Kanchi
Shankaracharya
in
the
evening
on
the
same
day
to
discuss
with
him
the
Ayodhya
issue,
and
this
gives
rise
to
apprehensions
about
his
government’s
real
intentions.
It
was
in
this
backdrop
that
the
AIMPLB
came
out
with
a
categorical
statement.
It
said:
if
any
negotiation
is
to
take
place,
“the
prime
minister’s
office
(PMO)
should
get
involved
directly,
in
a
transparent
manner,
instead
of
through
individuals
claiming
to
be
working
in
their
own
capacity
when
in
fact
the
PMO
is
very
much
involved”
(The
Hindu,
February
5).
But
it
is
also
certain
that
if
the
government
goes
out
of
its
way
to
placate
the
VHP
hawks
who
are
out
to
destroy
the
very
secular
fabric
of
our
body-politic,
if
the
judicial
process
is
circumvented
in
the
case,
it
will
have
serious
repercussions
for
our
national
unity
and
civilised
existence.
History
is
replete
with
episodes
in
which
attempts
to
appease
the
blood-thirsty
demonic
forces
were
made
and
yet
such
forces
grew
to
become
a
menace
to
humanity
itself.
The
way
Britain
and
France
tried
to
appease
Hitler
and
Hitler
then
become
a
threat
to
them
is
just
one
case
in
point.
Needless
to
say,
such
attempts
need
to
be
nipped
in
the
bud.
Regardless
of
their
differences
in
other
spheres,
all
the
secular
forces
in
the
country
have
to
rise
to
the
occasion,
and
these
include
the
forces
that
are
at
the
moment
on
the
other
side
of
the
fence.
Against
this
threat,
secular
forces
have
to
unitedly
mobilise
the
masses
of
our
great
country
who
are
eminently
secular.
The
situation
brooks
no
complacency,
nor
any
delay.